Agent 47 visits misty, rainy Dartmoor with the goal of eliminating Alexa Carlisle, one of the high-ranking members of Providence. However, Hitman 3’s Dartmoor location offers a unique gameplay change in the form of the Mission Story “Means, Motive and Opportunity.”
This story involves 47 disguising himself as a private detective in order to investigate the murder of Alexa’s brother, Zachary Carlisle. He’ll have to gather evidence, interrogate suspects, and check alibis as he attempts to solve this locked room murder mystery. And, of course, if you manage to accuse the killer, 47 will have the opportunity to assassinate Alexa while she is completely unguarded.
This guide features a step by step walkthrough to locate all clues and intel during the “Means, Motive and Opportunity” mission, as well as options for killing Alexa once the mission is completed.
Murder Mystery Obtaining the Private Investigator Disguise
First, you’ll need to subdue and take the outfit of the private investigator Alexa has hired to look into Zachary’s death. Sneak through the bushes as he approaches the mansion. Watch out for the maids and gardeners in this area, as many of them are Enforcers who will notice that you do not belong here.
Distract the PI by throwing a coin in his direction before subduing him. Alternately, wait until he has entered the main hallway inside the mansion. This hallway is unguarded and has plenty of cabinets for 47 to hide in. However, there are guards at the door of the house, so you’ll either need to sneak in through a window or drop all illegal items so that you can be frisked by the guards and enter safely.
Once you’re wearing the PI disguise, the butler Mr Fernsby will take you to meet Alexa, who will demand that you solve Zachary’s murder. Follow Fernsby to the scene of the crime.
Hitman 3 Dartmoor Investigating Zachary Carlisle’s Room
There are six clues to be found at the crime scene. They are:
- Zachary’s body (scan with camera)
- The bottle of whiskey on Zachary’s nightstand (scan with camera)
- Zachary’s laptop
- Zachary’s suicide note – on the table by the window
- Hidden room – use Instinct to identify a book in the bookcase that can be pulled
- Mansion floor plan – next to the mirror inside the hidden room
Talk to each member of the Carlisle family located around the manor to get their alibi for the night of the murder. Some alibis can be confirmed or disproved by examining items belonging to the suspects.
- Patrick Carlisle – Library. Confirm his alibi by speaking to Rosie the Maid in the Staff Room
- Edward Carlisle – Dining Room. He and Gregory were together at the time of death.
- Gregory Carlisle – Sitting Room. He and Edward were together at the time of death
- Emma Carlisle – Sitting Room.
- Rebecca Carlisle – Trophy Room. Confirm her alibi by checking the laptop in her bedroom.
After interrogating the suspects, only Emma is lacking an alibi. However, things are not as simple as they seem. We still don’t know who wrote Zachary’s suicide note, nor why the murder was committed.
Next, investigate the rooms of the mansion to find more clues.
A number of rooms in the mansion contain clues. The easiest way to investigate them all is to start in Mr. Fernsby’s Office, as it will net you the Master Key which unlocks all other doors.
Mr. Fernsby’s Office
Break down the door using a Crowbar. If you didn’t bring one with you, there’s one ripe for the taking near the delivery vans by the Kitchen. Grab the Master Key from the shelf. In addition, pick up the following clues:
- Zachary’s Half-Burned Diary – In the fireplace
- Mr. Fernsby’s List – On the desk
- Mr. Fernsby’s Pills – On the windowsill
Once you have the Master Key, you can find clues in the following rooms:
- Portrait of Montgomery Carlisle (Scan with camera)
- Muddy Footprints – On the terrace (Scan with camera)
- Edward Carlisle’s Speech (Scan with camera)
- Documents (Scan with camera)
- Rebecca’s Laptop
- Rebecca’s Notebook (Scan with camera)
Emma & Gregory’s Room
- Muddy Footprints (Scan with camera)
- Letter from Emma’s Mother – On nightstand
- Greenhouse Keychain – Next to folding screen
- Bulldog Cane – Next to fireplace
- Broken Equipment
- Poison Dosage Table (scan with camera)
Use the Bulldog Cane from Gregory & Emma’s Room on the switches to unlock a Hidden Room. Inside the Hidden Room is Montgomery’s Long-Lost Letter
Now, Agent 47 has all the clues he needs to solve this mystery. Return to Mr. Fernsby to inform him that you are ready to speak with Alexa Carlisle.
Another Death in the Family
At this point, it is recommended that you save your game because you have the option to earn a trophy here.
Once you’ve collected every single clue listed above, do not return and speak to Mr. Fernsby. Instead, head to the garden and pick up a wrench sitting on the table. Then, return to the greenhouse and repair the Broken Lab Equipment you found earlier.
Now, simply wait while continuing to wear the private investigator disguise. Emma, who has realized what you are up to, will use the repaired equipment and poison Alexa Carlisle’s tea, killing the Carlisle family matriarch in the same way her poor brother died. This will earn you the trophy “Another Death in the Family”
Once you’ve gotten that trophy, time to re-load your save and solve that mystery!
Solving the Mystery
Once you’ve talked to Mr. Fernsby, follow him into Alexa Carlisle’s office.
Although you know the truth of the matter, you have the option of accusing three different people: Emma, Mr. Fernsby, or Zachary himself. Emma is the killer, but you have enough evidence to frame either of the other two and have Alexa believe you. Each unlocks a different Feat, so you might want to save her and redo this choice.
Alexa will offer you a reward at this point. It is recommended that you take the Case File reward, as obtaining this information is also a mission goal. However, you can also choose Money as a reward if you wish.
Eliminating Alexa Carlisle & Securing the Case File
Once she has given 47 his reward, Alexa Carlisle will retire to the balcony outside her office, where she will be completely alone. If 47 told her that Zachary committed suicide, she will throw herself off the balcony and do the job herself. If he accused Emma or Mr. Fernsby, 47 will be responsible for eliminating his target.
You can easily push Alexa off her balcony when she is not looking at you. Alternately, if you are carrying poison, you can put it in the teacup on her desk, which she will drink from. Of course, you can also shoot or garrote her while she is alone.
If you chose Money as your reward, you will need to unlock her safe to grab the Case File. The code to Alexa’s safe is 1975. (The numbers are written on four objects around her office: the clock, telescope, fireplace and moose head.)
As long as Agent 47 continues to wear the Private Investigator disguise, he can safely exit the mansion and complete the mission without arousing any suspicion from guards or staff.
Make sure to check out TechRaptor’s other Hitman 3 guides to help Agent 47 complete the many unique challenges which this game offers!